Transient master piece, or re-heated lasagna?

It doesn’t matter if it’s a certain album that holds your attention for months, or a favourite series of TV that you must have the box set for in case of a rainy day – it seems there are some things you are compelled to see again and again. There are books I own which are creased and re read until they are well worn and wrinkled and there are DVD’s which I can’t seem to get enough of.

These things are to art what soup or bangers and mash are to food – comfort! I used to think that something had to be truly great to stay in your memory and affections over a long period of time and be enduring enough to be put through viewing after viewing, but I’m not sure that’s true anymore. When I think about some of the things love to watch or read again and again, I don’t think the entire list is made up of classics, epics or milestones from the world’s greatest minds. To be honest, there are actually some quite embarrassing things on there which other people might not even sit through once before changing channel or picking up another book.

Therefore, I am led to believe it is all about swings and roundabouts and different strokes for different folks. There must be some kind of mysterious power, element of taste or connection we have with certain things that give them a longevity with us and compel us to hoard or collect them for moments where we’re bored or a little blue.

I began thinking about this when I saw Deborah Warner and Fiona Shaw’s production of T.S Eliot’s The Wasteland at Wilton’s Music Hall last weekend. I was working as an usher and so ended up catching the performance three times in one day. At first it confused me, then it intrigued me and the third time it completely captivated me and left me wanting to persuade the company to keep the run going for another week. Besides, the theatre was to be overtaken the next day by Barbara Windsor’s new game show, something I’m sure we can all do without. I wondered whether it was the feeling of being in the right place at the right time; seeing a revival of a famous production during a limited run; feeling young and excited about seeing a great performer deliver a great text in an unforgettable venue.

Although I was obliged to watch the 40 minute show three times, I felt like I could have paid to watch it dozens more to soak up everything it had to offer. Perhaps it was because it was a masterpiece by a man recognised as a genius – although, it didn’t impress the queen mother who described Eliot as a ‘very strange man who came to the palace to read me a poem called ‘the desert.’ Although I was thrilled by it, some others seemed less impressed and bored by the prospect of having to watch the show multiple times.

So I finish with a question – what gives something it’s longevity, as there seems to be no golden rule which can make a piece of art last for ever for absolutely every viewer. What for you makes something stick and what indeed, are the things that are on your list of necessities for revisiting, re-watching or re reading?

This post was written by Peter Reed, our International Liaison.

6 responses to “Transient master piece, or re-heated lasagna?”

  1. Letty

    Who wrote this? Can I guess it was either John East or Pete Reed?

    Longevity is all about the experience you have while you watch/read something for the first time. I bet there was something significant, or a change of mood that influenced you to view this show differently each time.

  2. Mojo Jojo

    Well it sure ain’t me

    I’m a Barbara Windsor Super Fan

  3. harry

    no.. no… no… notorious!!!

    Guilty Pleasure of the highest order, i watched it 6 times in the 1st week of owning the dvd, good times aplenty there!

    most things i like to watch/hear/ see over and over and over are in fact rubbish… Weird really.

  4. Jemima

    EXTREMELY LOUD AND INCREDIBLY CLOSE – heartbreaking.

  5. Sian Ni M

    Interesting question – I suppose it depends really. Some things I watch childhood favorites that are so imbedded in my mind at this point that just hearing the title music makes me giddy (eg once upon a time, in a galaxy far, far away….). Other favorites however, I’m not so sure. Many movies that I watch over again are either unpleasant, violent, slow-paced, or harrowing, and I still go back. You couldn’t necessarily compare movies like The Life Aquatic and Festen in many experiential ways – but in their own particular style, they perfectly captured a truth. And are pretty emotionally rewarding.

    Or maybe I’m talking *&$! (rubbish) seeing as I’ve watched the Labyrinth about fifty times, while I’ve watched my ‘respectable favourite’s – The Life Aquatic, Cinema Paradiso, 12 Angry Men etc – only about five. Blaaaaah

  6. francesca

    oh Labrynth is *totally* respectable ;)

Leave a Reply

  • The 2010 festival team are all now sleeping...but wait for the 2011 team and their applications, which will open soon!
  • What a lovely weekend (if we say so ourselves) thanks for everyone who made it, you were all wonderfully understanding and supportive.
  • First blog post of the weekend:http://www.accidentalfestival.com/2010/2010/05/live-feed-accidental-workshops-1555/
  • SO!! Who's coming to the Accidental Jam Music Night FREE at the Bar Revolution in Clapham tonight? I am ;) (over 18s only)